- White-fronted Tyrannulet (Zeledon's)
 - White-fronted Tyrannulet (White-fronted)
+4
 - White-fronted Tyrannulet (White-fronted)
Watch
 - White-fronted Tyrannulet (Zeledon's)
Listen

White-fronted Tyrannulet Phyllomyias zeledoni Scientific name definitions

John W. Fitzpatrick, Josep del Hoyo, Guy M. Kirwan, and Nigel Collar
Version: 1.1 — Published October 25, 2022
Revision Notes

Sign in to see your badges

Introduction

Although originally described as a separate species, White-fronted Tyrannulet has, for many years, been lumped with Rough-legged Tyrannulet. Recent studies, however, have shed additional light on these two birds, and they are once again considered separate, baed on morphological, vocal, and genetic differences. White-fronted Tyrannulet has a broad distribution in southern Central America and northern South America, inhabiting the canopy of humid tropical and upper tropical evergreen forests of Costa RIca, Panama, Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, and Peru. It is a generally uncommon and inconspicuous tyrannulet that is predominantly olive above, with a gray cap, yellowish underparts, and two yellow wingbars. Most often a bird of the canopy, it changes perches often and may flick wings actively. Its typical vocalization is a strident pseet, which is either delivered singly or in a series.

Field Identification

The White-fronted Tyrannulet is a generally uncommon and inconspicuous tyrannulet that is predominantly olive above, with a gray cap, yellowish underparts, and two yellow wingbars. There is a narrow, dusky line through the eye, and a rather indistinct white supraloral streak that is widest over the lores and on the forehead, and meets on the forehead. The cheeks are indistinctly grizzled gray and white, the throat is whitish, and the eyes can be whitish tan to reddish brown. The bill is short, with a pale-pinkish mandible variably tipped dark. The underparts are a rather untidy yellow gray, becoming yellower medially. The wings are dusky with two yellow wingbars, the tertials edged with yellow. Most often a bird of the canopy, it changes perches often and may flick wings actively. Typical vocalization is a strident pseet, which is either delivered singly or in a series.

Similar Species

An "obscure bird, often hard to identify" (1), although when seen well, the bumpy legs (that lent the formerly conspecific Rough-legged Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias burmeisteri) its name, are a useful identification feature. Most bluntly, similarly sized tyrannulets in range usually lack the connecting white forecrown and pale mandible of present species, and at least some show dark mark on ear coverts; however, these differences are not always apparent and much confusion can arise, particularly with other Phyllomyias, Tyrannulus, and Zimmerius tyrannulets.

The Slender-footed Tyrannulet (Zimmerius gracilipes) is similar in appearance, and theoretically could overlap broadly in range, although it favors lower elevations. It is smaller, with an all-dark bill, less red irides, less well-defined wingbars and supraloral stripe, and more grayish on the cheeks (1, 2). The White-fronted Tyrannulet is also slightly larger than the Slender-footed Tyrannulet , with a sharper, whiter continuous eyestripe that narrows above and behind the eye (3).

Similarly, the Yellow-crowned Tyrannulet (Tyrannulus elatus), which also has a broad distribution, is slightly smaller, with a lighter crown, a less well-defined supraloral, grayer cheeks, and an (oft concealed) yellow patch on the crown.

The broadly distributed Forest Elaenia (Myiopagis gaimardii) is larger, with bolder streaks on the breast, less pink on the mandible, and a white crown patch (that may be concealed).

The Sooty-headed Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias griseiceps) is found from Panama to Peru, and is similar in appearance, but has a wholly dark bill and lacks wingbars.

The Yellow-olive Flatbill (Tolmomyias sulphurescens) is also broadly distributed, but is larger, with a broader bill (4).

The Mistletoe Tyrannulet (Zimmerius parvus) may overlap in range in Costa Rica and Panama. It has an all-dark bill and less-obvious wingbars (5). The formerly conspecific Venezuelan Tyrannulet (Zimmerius petersi) of coast north-central Venezuela also has an all-dark bill, and has more white above and below the eyes (4).

The Pale-tipped Tyrannulet (Inezia caudata), which may overlap in range in Colombia and Venezuela, has white outer rectrices and a wholly dark bill.

Also in Colombia, the leucophrys subspecies of Yellow Tyrannulet (Capsiempis flaveola) may cause confusion, as it also has a white supraloral area, two yellow wingbars, and a pale base to the mandible (sometimes subtle). The White-fronted Tyrannulet can be differentiated by its paler mandible, less yellow appearance, and whitish, not yellow throat.

The Sclater's Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias sclateri) may be confused in southern Peru (although it typically favors higher elevations), but it can be differentiated from the present species by its slatier crown, less pale mandible (although still pale at base), and more white on the forehead, wingbars, and underparts (1).

For differences from previously conspecific Phyllomyias burmeisteri (no geographical overlap) see Systematics.

Plumages

Juvenile

Juvenile resembles adult.

Definitive Basic (Adult) Plumage

The crown and hindneck are slate colored, with the upperparts olive-green. Two wingbars are present. The forehead is white, the throat is a duller white. The breast and sides are olive, with yellow undertail coverts. Sexes alike.

Molts

No information.

Bare Parts

Bill

The maxilla is black or fuscous, with the mandible pale pink (nominate subspecies and subspecies leucogonys).

Iris and Facial Skin

Iris is reddish brown or pale sandy gray.

Tarsi and Toes

The tarsi and toes are black or fuscous.

Measurements

Linear Measurements

10·7–11·5 cm.

Mass

9·8–10·8 g.

Systematics History

Phyllomyias zeledoni was originally described as a separate species, and was recognized as such by many (e.g., 6, 7) before eventually being lumped into an expanded Phyllomyias burmeisteri (8, 9). Some authors continued to recognize the two as distinct species on the basis of differences in vocalizations (10, 11), but most treated the two as conspecific owing to a lack of formal analyses (e.g., 12). Recent work (13, 14, 15, 16, 17) has shed additional light on the taxa, and we split Phyllomyias zeledoni and Rough-legged Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias burmeisteri) on the basis of morphological, vocal, and genetic differences.

In their assessment of the taxa, del Hoyo and Collar (18), using the Tobias et al. (19) criteria, form which the scores in brackets are derived, found Phyllomyias zeledoni differs in its olive-green versus dull bluish-gray crown (or, in case of subspecies viridiceps of Phyllomyias zeledoni, forecrown) [3]; lack of white supercilium [2]; and typical song or call (a repeated single overslurred “pseet”) comprising considerably lower [3] and slightly shorter [1] notes (13). In a detailed analysis of vocalizations of the two taxa, Parra-Hernández et al. (16) found songs of the two were significantly different, and that the two were nearly sympatric in northern Bolivia, but seemed to segregate by elevation, with Phyllomyias zeledoni occurring at lower elevations and drier habitat. Harvey et al. (15) also recovered deep genetic divergence between the two taxa.

Along with Phyllomyias zeledoni, Phyllomyias burmeisteri was long placed in Acrochordopus because of distinctively serrated tarsus, but tarsal scutellation now known to be unreliable as generic character in this family.

Subspecies

Wetmore (10) treated the subspecies leucogonys as a distinct species, but in their analyses of songs, Parra-Hernández et al. (16) found that leucogonys song grouped with the rest of zeledoni, and was not significantly different.


EBIRD GROUP (MONOTYPIC)

White-fronted Tyrannulet (Zeledon's) Phyllomyias zeledoni zeledoni Scientific name definitions

Systematics History

Formerly treated as conspecific with P. burmeisteri.

Distribution

Costa Rica and western Panama (Chiriquí).

Identification Summary

Nominate subspecies has crown slaty gray, a narrow whitish supercilium, and a white eyering. The white of the lores connects across forehead. Mandible is pale pink.


EBIRD GROUP (POLYTYPIC)

White-fronted Tyrannulet (White-fronted) Phyllomyias zeledoni [leucogonys Group]


SUBSPECIES

Phyllomyias zeledoni wetmorei Scientific name definitions

Distribution

Santa Marta Mountains (20) and Sierra de Perijá, on Colombia–Venezuela border.

Identification Summary

Subspecies wetmorei is darker overall.


SUBSPECIES

Phyllomyias zeledoni viridiceps Scientific name definitions

Distribution

Mountains of northern Venezuela (Carabobo to Miranda).

Identification Summary

Subspecies <em>viridiceps</em> has slate-gray forehead, rest of crown olive-green.


SUBSPECIES

Phyllomyias zeledoni bunites Scientific name definitions

Distribution

Chimantá-tepui, in southeastern Bolívar (eastern Venezuela).

Identification Summary

Subspecies bunites has a tiny bill, and the dark gray of the crown extends to the hindneck.


SUBSPECIES

Phyllomyias zeledoni leucogonys Scientific name definitions

Distribution

Eastern Andes from Colombia south to southeastern Peru (northwestern Puno).

Identification Summary

Subspecies leucogonys differs from nominate in its larger bill, duller green back, and lightly paler yellow underparts with less prominent flammulations. Mandible is pale pink.

Related Species

Phyllomyias zeledoni appears to be sister to Rough-legged Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias burmeisteri), with which it was formerly considered conspecific. Together, these two species appear to be sister to a small clade of three species, including Black-capped Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias nigrocapillus), Tawny-rumped Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias uropygialis), and Ashy-headed Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias cinereiceps) (15).

Fossil History

Nothing known.

Distribution

The range of White-fronted Tyrannuletis broken up into five rather disjunt regions, each of which corresponds with one of the five recognized subspecies. It is found in the mountains of Costa Rica and western Panama, the Sierra de Perijá on the Colombian/Venezuelan border, the coastal mountains of n Venezuela, the tepuis of southern Venezuela, and the East Andes of Colombia, Ecuador and Peru (21, 22, 11, 23, 24, 25, 4, 26)

Historical Changes to the Distribution

None reported.

Habitat

Canopy of humid tropical and upper tropical evergreen forest, sometimes venturing to edges and older second growth. At 800–2800 m in Costa Rica (5) and 900-1850m Panama (27), 475–1800 m in Colombia, 100-1800m (usually above 800m) in Venezuela (4), 500–1500 m in Ecuador (28), and 750–1600 m in eastern Peru (29).

Movement

Apparently resident.

Dispersal and Site Fidelity

No information.

Feeding

Food Capture and Consumption

An active forager, moving along the canopy or midstory gleaning and hover-gleaning. Joins mixed-species flocks containing other tyrannids (Tyrannidae), as well as foliage-gleaners (Furnariidae), parulids (Parulidae) and tanagers (Thraupidae), foraging mainly in midstory or subcanopy, but will descend much lower (28, 4).

Diet

Major Food Items

Arthropods, small berries, leafhoppers, but very poorly studied. No known differences from Rough-legged Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias burmeisteri).

Vocalizations

Vocal Development

No information.

Vocal Array

Vocabulary is apparently very limited with a fast series of notes that could be named Song and the same note uttered singly which then could be described Call. Alternatively, given single notes are often given in long leisurely-paced series during early morning (suggesting a Dawn song), this vocalization could be named Song despite its lower complexity, the note series then a call type. We therefore avoid this terminology:

Note series. A fast series of some 4-12 high-pitched pseet notes, often slightly descending in pitch, and sometimes introduced by a few single pseet notes (see next vocalization). Pace of delivery 2.5‒3.0 notes/s (13). Such series is typically given only once.

Pseet. A single high-pitched overslurred note pseet, identical to a single note of the Song, and typically repeated several times at a rather steady slow pace. When birds are very excited, notes may become disyllabic psee-seet. Note duration 0.22‒0.37s, maximum frequency 6.4‒7.1kHz (13).

Other. Trills in interaction have been described (11), and a descending pseeuuuu longer than normal Pseet call (29).

Geographic Variation

Has been treated as conspecific with Rough-legged Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias burmeisteri). Vocalizations of both species are structurally very similar, but show a consistent difference in maximum frequency and note duration, without any indication of clinal change (13, 14). There is thus an abrupt change in voice between populations of both species around the Peruvian/Bolivian border. Vocal variation among the various subspecies of present species has not been studied yet.

Phenology

Little information. Pseet and fast Note series have been recorded in most months of the year, but there may be regional differences.

Daily Pattern of Vocalizing

Long series of Pseet notes uttered at steady pace are uttered starting early in the morning (a possible Dawn song). Further during the morning, both Pseet notes and Note series can be heard. Less vocal the remainder of the day.

Places of Vocalizing

Typically calls when perched on a thin branch from mid-elevation to sub-canopy of trees.

Sex Differences

No information.

Social Content and Presumed Functions of Vocalizations

The species is not very vocal and rather uncommon, which makes it hardly surprising there is very little information. Uttering steady Pseet notes at dawn could have a territorial function. Different function of both daytime vocalizations unclear.

Nonvocal Sounds

None documented.

Social and Interspecific Behavior

Degree of Sociality

Typically singly, in pairs, or in small groups. Will join mixed-species flocks in the canopy and midstory (28).

Phenology

Nest building in early August in Panama (30).

Nest Site

Site Characteristics

Nest sited 12m above ground on a horizontal canopy branch of a live tree, in a mossy area just before the branch forked (30).

Nest

Construction

A pair were observed bringing strands of moss during nest building. Both members of the pair were observed contributing to the nest, although one adult worked on the nest at a time. Birds would occasionally sit in the nest while working on it. One of the adults sang near the nest, but not actually on it, throughout the observation period (30).

Structure and Composition

Nest is a cup-shaped structure, apparently constructed solely of moss (30).

Demography and Populations

There is no information related to topics such as age at first breeding, life span and survivorship, dispersal, or population regulation for White-fronted Tyrannulet.

Population Status

Very uncommon to rare, and local in Venezuela, Colombia, and Peru; uncommon to locally common elsewhere; perhaps often overlooked.

Not globally threatened (Least Concern).

Distribution of the Scientific Name: Phyllomyias zeledoni - Range Map
Enlarge
  • Year-round
  • Migration
  • Breeding
  • Non-Breeding
Distribution of the Scientific Name: Phyllomyias zeledoni

Recommended Citation

Fitzpatrick, J. W., J. del Hoyo, G. M. Kirwan, and N. Collar (2022). White-fronted Tyrannulet (Phyllomyias zeledoni), version 1.1. In Birds of the World (B. K. Keeney, Editor). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, NY, USA. https://doi.org/10.2173/bow.roltyr1.01.1
Birds of the World

Partnerships

A global alliance of nature organizations working to document the natural history of all bird species at an unprecedented scale.