- Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant
 - Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant
+3
 - Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant
Watch
 - Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant
Listen

Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant Ochthoeca fumicolor Scientific name definitions

Harold F. Greeney, Andrew Farnsworth, Gary Langham, and Guy M. Kirwan
Version: 1.2 — Published October 25, 2022
Revision Notes

Sign in to see your badges

Introduction

The Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is a small flycatcher of montane northwestern South America. Ranging from southwestern Venezuela south along the Andes to Bolivia, the species prefers stunted forest near treeline between 2600 and 4200 meters in elevation. It is a subtly colored, but attractive species: rufous brown above with a broad white-buff superciliary, an ashy throat, cinnamon underparts, and blackish wings marked by two cinnamon wingbars. It often perches conspicuously, twitching its tail and occasionally making soft, sibilant calls. Its nest and eggs are known, but nothing has been published concering other aspects of its reproductive ecology.

Field Identification

Like other species of Ochthoeca, Brown-backed Chat-Tyrants have a compact body shape, generally upright posture with a protruding breast when perched, moderately long tails, moderately long tarsi, and a triangular, moderately compressed and broad-based bill with rictal bristles extending slightly beyond the middle of the bill (1). Overall, they have a stout, flat-headed appearance. The face is largely grayish, with a long, broad buffy white superciliary. The remaining upperparts are brown. The wings are blackish with two rufous wing bars, while the tail is dusky with white outer edges. The underparts are cinnamon rufous. Females are similar but slightly duller overall (2).

Similar Species

The Crowned Chat-Tyrant (Silvicultrix frontalis) is similar to the present species, but smaller, browner overall, grayish below, and lacks prominent wing bars. Another similar congener, Rufous-breasted Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca rufipectoralis) has a white, rather than cinnamon-rufous, belly (3). d'Orbigny's Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca oenanthoides), differs from Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant in having a white superciliary, grayer upperparts, and almost unmarked wings (2).

Plumages

Juvenile and Formative Plumage

The immature plumages are not well described, but juveniles are said to be similar to adults but overall a warmer shade of brown above and without gray on the chin (4).

Definitive Basic (Adult) Plumage

Nominate subspecies has a broad whitish supercilium extending from the lores to the side of the hindcrown, becoming more ochraceous behind eye; crown warm brown; back rufescent brown, becoming more rufous brown towards rump; wings dusky or blackish, two prominent rufous wingbars, lower one more conspicuous; tail dusky to blackish, white outer webs of outer rectrices; throat and lower face grayish; underparts cinnamon-rufous, undertail coverts buff. Female somewhat paler and duller below.

Molts

No information.

Bare Parts

Bill

Black.

Iris and Facial Skin

Iris is dark brown to “clear brown” (5).

Tarsi and Toes

Black

Measurements

General

  • Total length — 14·5–16 cm.
  • Mass — 16–19 g.

Linear Measurements

Ochthoeca fumicolor brunneifrons (♀♀)

  • Wing – 81, 86.5 mm (n = 2; 6).
  • Tail – 71.5, 76.5 mm (n = 2; 6).
  • Culmen [from base?] – 14 mm (n = 2; 6).
  • Tarsus – 22.5, 24 mm (n = 2; 6).

Ochthoeca fumicolor brunneifrons (gender unknown)

  • Wing – 85.5-94 mm (n = ?; 6).
  • Tail – 74-81.5 mm (n = ?; 6).
  • Culmen [from base?] – 13.5-15 mm (n = ?; 6).
  • Tarsus – 23.5-24 mm (n = ?; 6).

Ochthoeca fumicolor ferruginea (♂♂)

  • Wing – 80 mm (n = 1, holotype; 7).
  • Tail – 69.25 mm (n = 1, holotype; 7).
  • Exposed Culmen – 11 mm (n = 1, holotype; 7).
  • Culmen from base – 15.5 mm (n = 1, holotype; 7).
  • Tarsus – 20.5 mm (n = 1, holotype; 7).

Mass

  • Ochthoeca fumicolor fumicolor 16.5 g (♂) (8).

Systematics History

Ochthoeca fumicolor is often treated as conspecific with Rufous-browed Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca superciliosa) by most recent authors, although there have been suggestions that multiple species were involved (e.g., 9, 10, 11); Cory and Hellmayr (12) did treat superciliosa as specifically distinct, on the basis on marked plumage differentiation, and the justification for subsequent treatments as conspecific with fumicolor are not clear. Zimmer's (7:8) suggestion that the then newly described taxon ferruginea, from the north end of the Western and Central Andes of Colombia, "shows a decided trend in the direction of superciliosa," and that the characters of superciliosa are "no more than extremes of characteristics found in fumicolor and its conspecies..." may be start of the trend to treat these taxa as conspecific. However, no intermediates are known, and superciliosa occurs north of the Táchira depression.

In their assessment of the complex, del Hoy and Collar (13), using the Tobias et al. (14) criteria, from which the scores in brackets are derived, found that Ochthoeca superciliosa differs in its broad rufous versus narrower whitish supercilium [3]; single versus double wingbar [3]; darker crown and upperparts [1]; richer rufous underparts (ns[1]); and smaller size than adjacent populations of Ochthoeca fumicolor fumicolor [shorter wing, effect size −2.23, score 2]. Examination (unpublished) of vocalizations also hints at differences between Ochthoeca superciliosa and the Ochthoeca fumicolor group; formal vocal and genetic studies needed.

Geographic Variation

Subspecies vary mainly in the cinnamon tones of breast and color of the supercilium.

Subspecies


SUBSPECIES

Ochthoeca fumicolor fumicolor Scientific name definitions

Systematics History

Ochthoeca fumicolor Sclater, 1856, Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, vol. 24, p. 28, plate 117—"Bogota," Colombia.

Distribution

Andes of southwestern Venezuela (southern Táchira) and northern part of eastern cordillera in Colombia (south to Cundinamarca).

Identification Summary


SUBSPECIES

Ochthoeca fumicolor ferruginea Scientific name definitions

Systematics History

Ochthoeca fumicolor ferruginea Zimmer, 1937, American Museum Novitates, no. 930 p. 7—Santa Elena, 9,000 ft., Antioquia, Colombia.

Distribution

Northern part of central and western Andes of Colombia (Antioquia).

Identification Summary

Subspecies <em>ferruginea</em> resembles berlepschi but has more white in outer tail feathers and a shorter, buffy supercilium.


SUBSPECIES

Ochthoeca fumicolor brunneifrons Scientific name definitions

Systematics History

Ochthoeca oenanthoides brunneifrons Berlepsch and Stolzmann, 1896, Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, vol. 64, p. 355—"In Peruvia centrali et septentrionali et in Ecuadoria" [Maraynioc, Junin, Peru] (7, 15).

Distribution

Central and western Andes of Colombia (south from Caldas and Cauca) south to northern and central Peru (on western slope to Cajamarca and on eastern slope to Junín).

Identification Summary

Subspecies <em>brunneifrons</em> has long, conspicuous buff supercilium , as well as broad rufous wingbars .


SUBSPECIES

Ochthoeca fumicolor berlepschi Scientific name definitions

Systematics History

Ochthoeca fumicolor berlepschi Hellmayr, 1914, Novitates Zoologicae, no. 21, p. 167—Malaga, Bolivia.

Distribution

Southeastern Peru (Cuzco, Puno) and west and central Bolivia (La Paz, Cochabamba).

Identification Summary

Subspecies <em>berlepschi</em> has rather short, narrow, dirty whitish supercilium, birds from Cochabamba have browner crown.

Related Species

Ochthoeca fumicolor is likely mostly closely related to the formerly conspecific Rufous-browed Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca superciliosa), but Ochthoeca superciliosa has not been included in any phylogenetic study. In a large molecular phylogeny, Harvey et al. (16) found that Ochthoeca fumicolor was sister to a clade that included Rufous-breasted Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca rufipectoralis), Piura Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca piurae), d'Orbigny's Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca oenanthoides), and White-browed Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca leucophrys). In an earlier study of the genus, Vuilleumier (8) also suggested a close relationship with Ochthoeca oenanthoides, Ochthoeca piurae, and Ochthoeca leucophrys.

Fossil History

None reported.

Distribution

Brown occurs in the Andes of extreme southwestern Venezuela, south of the Táchira depression and the northern part of eastern cordillera in Colombia, southward through most of the Colombian and Ecudorian Andes to west-central Bolivia (La Paz, Cochabamba) (4, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21).

Historical Changes to the Distribution

None described.

Habitat

The Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant inhabits shrub-bordered pastures, montane dwarf forests and forest borders, and semi-humid Polylepis woodland, and open paramo with Espeletia (3, 4, 22).

Across its extensive latitudinal range, it is most commonly found at around 2200–4200 m (4, 2, 18, 19, 21), occasionally found as low as 1800 m (3) and as high as c. 4500 m (23).

Movement

Resident.

Dispersal and Site Fidelity

No information, but territories in northeastern Ecuador appear to be occupied across multiple years (H.F. Greeney personal observation).

Feeding

Food Capture and Consumption

Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant searches for prey while perched on branches, rarely more than 2 m above ground and usually near main stem. It also occasionally clings to an upright stem (4). In more open areas it forages from exposed perches such as the tops of stumps, Espeletia plants, fence posts, bushes, or grass clumps, sallying to hawk insects from the air and from the ground (3, 24, 21). Foraging birds may either return to the same perch or, occasionally may move to a new perch following a foraging sally. They occasionally hover-glean prey from the ground, from vegetation, or from other substrates (4).

Diet

The diet of Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is poorly known, but stomach contents have been vaguely described as “insects” (5).

Food Selection and Storage

Information needed.

Nutrition and Energetics

Information needed.

Metabolism and Temperature Regulation

Information needed.

Drinking, Pellet-Casting, and Defecation

Information needed.

Vocalizations

Vocal Array

Songs

Usually quiet, the song of Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is a weak but sharp, squeaky chatter, usually given in duet: “keek-kee-keek” or “keek-tede-keek” (lasting c. 1 second). Songs are repeated at very short intervals, usually from a perch but occasionally from cover.

Calls

They make a variety of calls, either while perched or in flight, a high-pitched “tsiu,” a soft “prip,” or a clear whistled “kleeeip” (25, 4).

Nonvocal Sounds

Song delivery is sometimes accompanied with wing-whirring (4).

Behavior

Generally conspicuous and often confiding, Brown-backed Chat-Tyrants perch erectly, with their tails held down. Upon landing on a perch, adults may spread their wings and tail widely, occasionally for long periods (4, 10). Alarmed birds may nervously flick their tail (3).

Locomotion

Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant rarely flies long distances, but may cover 20-30 m when moving between perches. Most flights involve short sallies, after which they return to the same (or nearby) perch (H.F. Greeney, personal observation).

Self-Maintenance

No information.

Agonistic Behavior

Territorial Behavior

This is apparently a rather territorial species (4), but this aspect of their natural history has not been well explored. During territorial disputes, adults make short, wobbling flights, and produce an audible whirring with their wings (4).

Sexual Behavior

Information needed.

Social and Interspecific Behavior

Degree of Sociality

Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant forages alone or in pairs (26, 27). Pairs may cover considerable distances while foraging (17), but may not closely associate with their mate while foraging (3).

Predation

Information needed.

Breeding

Despite several nests reported in the literature, as well as several published pictures of nests (28, 29, 30), the nesting biology of Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant remains rather poorly known. Nothing has been published concerning the behavior or appearance of nestlings, nor concerning adult behavior during nesting.

Phenology

Little information. In northeastern Ecuador, Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is said to nest from October to December (28). This is supported by eggs collected on 23 October by Kiff et al. (31).

Nest Site

One nest was built in a dense vine tangle hanging high over a dirt roadbank 1.5 m above the ground (31). Nests have also been found nestled withing clumps of grass along streams (28). No further information.

Nest

Form and Composition

The nest of Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is a bulky cup of moss and grass, lined with soft, fluffy puya fibres (31) or animal wool (28).

Dimensions

The nest collected by Kiff et al. (31) measured: external diameter, 12 × 11.5 cm; external height, 8 cm; inner cup width, 5.5 cm; inner cup depth 4.5 cm.

Eggs

The eggs of Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant have been described by several authors. Those described by Nehrkorn (32) are simply said to be from Colombia, and thus may refer to nominate fumicolor, ferruginea, or brunneifrons. Schönwetter (33), however, referred to Nehrkorn's (32) eggs as being from the eastern Andes, suggesting they may be of nominate fumifrons. Those described by Oates and Reid (34) are most likely those collected by T. K. Salmon (5), and are thus referable to ferruginea. The measurments and descriptions provided by Schönwetter (33) include both Nehrkorn's (32) and T. K. Salmon's (5) eggs. Those described by Kiff et al. (31) and Black M. (28) are of subspecies brunneifrons.

Shape

Short oval or short subelliptical (34, 31).

Surface Texture

Slightly glossy (34).

Color

Egg descriptions are all rather similar: cream colored with few small, dark brown spots (32); cream colored and lightly "speckled with deep purplish brown" (34); white, with a few small reddish or red-brown spots (5, 28); "creamy-white with a few scattered spots of rufous-brown and dark brown, mostly on the larger ends" (31).

Linear Dimensions

Egg dimensions have been reported several times in the literature: 19 × 15 mm (n = ?; 32); 19.1 × 15.2 mm (n = 2; 5); 19.3 × 14.0 mm, 19.8 × 15.2 mm (n = 2; 34); 21.5 × 12.8 (n = ?; 28); 19.46 × 15.12 mm, 20.24 × 15.74 mm (n = 2; 31); range 18.8–18.8 × 14.5–15.2 mm (33).

Mass

The fresh mass of eggs given by Schönwetter (33) was calculated (see 35) based on the dimensions of the eggs collected by Nehrkorn (32) and Salmon (5): 2.18 g. Mass, measured directly, of Ecuadorian eggs (fresh?) is reported to be 2.7 g (n = ?; 28).

Empty Shell Weight

Two eggs (31): 0.115 g, 0.131 g.

Incubation

In Ecuador, the incubation period is reported as 21 days (n = ?; 28). No further information.

Hatching

No information on the process or timing of hatching. In Ecuador, the nestling period is reported to last 25 days (n = ?; 28).

Young Birds

Information needed.

Parental Care

Information needed.

Cooperative Breeding

No information, but considered unlikely.

Brood Parasitism by Other Species

No information, but unlikely due to the elevation at which Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant nests.

Fledgling Stage

Information needed.

Immature Stage

Information needed.

Demography and Populations

There is no information related to topics such as age at first breeding, life span and survivorship, dispersal, or population regulation for Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant.

Measures of Breeding Activity

Clutch Size

2 eggs (34, 31).

Life Span and Survivorship

Information needed.

Disease and Body Parasites

Information needed.

Causes of Mortality

Information needed.

Population Spatial Metrics

Information needed.

Population Status

Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant is considered fairly common to common in most portions of its range, but population sizes and trends have not been quantified.

Population Regulation

Information needed.

Not globally threatened. The Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant has a large range is considered a species of Least Concern.

Effects of Human Activity

No effects of human activity on Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant have been directly measured, but burning and clearing of polylepis woodlands, for firewood and cattle grazing, are undoubtedly detrimentally impacting this species.

Management

Protected Populations

Ochthoeca fumicolor fumicolor

Parque Nacional El Tamá (36); Parque Nacional Natural Perijá (37, 38); Parque Nacional Natural El Cocuy (39); Reserva Biológica Carapanta (40); Parque Forestal Embalse del Neusa (41); Bosque Protector de Bogotá (42).

Ochthoeca fumicolor ferruginea

Reserva de Flora y Fauna Alto de Montefrío (43).

Ochthoeca fumicolor brunneifrons

Parque Nacional Natural Los Nevados (44); Parque Nacional Llanganates (45); Parque Nacional Cayambe-Coca (31); Parque Nacional Las Cajas (46); Reserva Ecológico Antisana (28); Reserva Biológico Guandera (47); Santuario Nacional Tabaconas-Namballe (48).

Ochthoeca fumicolor berlepschi

Parque Nacional Tunari (49); Parque Nacional Manú (50, 30); Santuario Histórico Machu Picchu (51).

Priorities for Future Research

As a bird of the high Andean paramo, brown deserves special conservation consideration, in the form of studies examining the effects of wide-spread burning and conversion of Andean habitats for grazing. Its basic natural history, especially diet and nesting, are poorly known, and knowledge of both will be key for planning conservation actions.

Acknowledgments

The PBNHS continues to support the field work of HFG in Ecuador and elsewhere. He also thanks the Association of Field Ornithologists for a Pamela and Alexander F. Skutch Research Award, Matt E. Kaplan and John V. Moore for generous contributions to the Population Biology, the John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation for the award of a fellowship, and the staff and guests of the Yanayacu Biological Station & Center for Creative Studies for their help in the field.

About the Author(s)

HAROLD F. GREENEY – After graduating from Wake Forest University (BSc, 1993; Commission 2nd Lieutenant, US Army Reserves), Harold hopped a plane to Ecuador and disappeared for a year into the jungle. For a full year he worked as a jungle guide at a remote tourist lodge in the Ecuadorian Amazon, using his spare time to study the life history and population ecology of butterflies. In 1994 he joined the graduate program in entomology at the University of Arizona, spending most of the next five years exploring tropical nature in Ecuador, concentrating his studies on the aquatic insects associated with bromeliads and other container habitats in the Amazon. During his trips back to the United States, Harold fulfilled his army obligations by serving as a Platoon Leader in the Army Reserves and leading convoy security teams during battlefield training of the 4th Infantry Division in southern California’s National Training Center. In 1999, armed with a Masters in entomology, binoculars, a butterfly net, and a notebook, Harold sold his worldly possessions and purchased a small piece of property in the cloud forests of eastern Ecuador. Subsisting on a modest garden, trout caught in the nearby river, and the chickens that came with the purchase, Harold lived in a semi-waterproof house with no electricity or running water and immersed himself in tropical biology. This bold move was the first step in pursuing his dream of creating a biological research station. A decade and a half later, as founder, owner, and director of research of the Yanayacu Biological Station and Center for Creative Studies, he had never once wavered in his quest, sharing his passion for art, creative writing, and science with numerous national and foreign students along the way. During this time he fell in love with the study of bird nests and the prolific publishing of his findings in scientific journals was recognized by the ornithological community through the prestigious Pamela & Alexander F. Skutch Award in 2005. His interest in insects, however, was undiminished and much of his time was also dedicated to publishing studies on caterpillars as part of a multi-national collaborative project funded by the National Science Foundation. In 2008, already with more than 100 peer-reviewed papers under his belt, Harold completed a PhD in ornithology through the University of Wroclaw. In 2013 he left his cloud forest home to begin a family closer to his US-based relatives. Then, in 2015, with the support of a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Fellowship, Harold began writing the Helm Field Guide to Antpittas and Gnateaters (52). Harold currently lives in Tucson, with his wife Lindsey Cohen and three children, Phoenix, River, and Tamia.

Distribution of the Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant - Range Map
Enlarge
  • Year-round
  • Migration
  • Breeding
  • Non-Breeding
Distribution of the Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant

Recommended Citation

Greeney, H. F., A. Farnsworth, G. Langham, and G. M. Kirwan (2022). Brown-backed Chat-Tyrant (Ochthoeca fumicolor), version 1.2. In Birds of the World (B. K. Keeney, Editor). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, NY, USA. https://doi.org/10.2173/bow.bbctyr1.01.2
Birds of the World

Partnerships

A global alliance of nature organizations working to document the natural history of all bird species at an unprecedented scale.